Hall of champions
Winners of the Taylor Memorial Cup and XHL Champions
2001 - The Marvel Knights
Chris Albright
Matt Baronak
Chad Cable
Jeremy Johnson
BJ Soliday
Fred Terwilliger
2003 - The Contenders
Ryan Drayer
Chad Hilliard
Ken Jeffery
Sean Mahaffey
Don Maicki
Brandon Reiter
Eric Stuby
2002 - The Punishers
Dave Colgan
Jeff Crooks
Jeremy Johnson
Larry Schuckers
Rob Stanley
Matt Yoder
Mike Yoder
2004 - The Colonials
Bob Anderson
Fred Terwilliger
Paul Decker
Bob Williams
John Hrusth
Shawn Williams
Jim Miller
2005 - The Contenders
Ryan Drayer
Brandon Reiter
Chad Hilliard
Rob Stanley
Ken Jeffrey
Eric Stuby
Sean Mahaffey
2006 - The Rogue
Jerred Amick
Rob Keith
Jason Iseler
Adam McKinley
Jeremy Johnson
Dennis Kirst
Dave Keith
2007 - The Rogue
Jerred Amick
Rob Keith
Jason Iseler
Adam McKinley
Jeremy Johnson
Dennis Kirst
Dave Keith
2008 - The Rogue
Jerred Amick
Rob Keith
Jason Iseler
Adam McKinley
Steve Kalgren
Dennis Kirst
Dave Keith
2009 - The Maniax
Clay Halpin
Dave Jewell
Cory Schuckers
Mike London
Kevin Smith
Garrett Mohney
Rob Stanley
2010 - The Maniax
Clay Halpin
Dave Jewell
Cory Schuckers
Cody Schuckers
Kevin Smith
Garrett Mohney
Rob Stanley
2011 - The Maniax
Clay Halpin
Dave Jewell
Cory Schuckers
Cody Schuckers
Kevin Smith
Chad Walter
Zach Smith
Rob Stanley
2012 - The Wolfpack
Joe Bussard
Mike Jacobson
Jarrod Currin
Adam McKinley
Derik Day
Greg Mohney
Henry Deible
Brandon Reiter
2013 - The Wolfpack
Joe Bussard
Mike Jacobson
Jarrod Currin
Adam McKinley
Derik Day
Greg Mohney
Henry Deible
Brandon Reiter
2014 - The Hooligans
Anthony Benanti
Steve Kalgren
Eric Llewellyn
James Nelson
Cody Schuckers
Cory Schuckers
Aaron Skerkavich
Stefan Smith
2015 - The Wolfpack
Andy Calvert
Mike Jacobson
Jarrod Currin
Adam McKinley
Derik Day
Dave Jewell
Steve Pompeii
Rob Stanley
2016 - The Colonials
Bob Anderson
Brian Anderson
Chad Walter
Fred Terwilliger
Phil Pompeii
Brandon Reiter
Joe Bussard
John Matchok
2017 - The Colonials
Bob Anderson
Brian Anderson
Fred Terwilliger
Mark Pisarcik
Kevin Smith
Phil Mace
John Matchok
Tim Herman
2018 - The Renegades
Josh Clontz
Pat Hunter
Mike Lehman
Derrian Matchock
Ben Reider
Joe Spencer
Denny Stinchcomb
Brandon Vollmer
2019 - The Renegades
Josh Clontz
Pat Hunter
Mike Lehman
Derrian Matchock
Gus Gates
Eric Llewellyn
Denny Stinchcomb
Brandon Vollmer
2020 - N/A
Due to the COVID-19 pandemic, no official season was played
2021 - Pink Team
Adam McKinley
Austin Boyd
Jerred Amick
John Matchock
Matt Cole
Ryan Johnson
Steve Capetta
2022 -The Colonials
Bob Anderson
Brian Anderson
Dan Fatula
Tim Herman (G)
John Matchock
Kevin Smith
Fred Terwilliger
Brandon Vollmer
2023 -The Knights
Andy Calvert
Nate Galentine
Jake Kline
Noah Kline
Clint Lingenfelter (G)
Brandon Reiter
Cory Schuckers
Brandon Vollmer